Skip to content
TownbriefSheffield
Sign in Subscribe
Tuesday, November 3, 2026 Sheffield, Massachusetts · Change town
Real Estate

Priced Sheffield Sales Cluster Under $105,000 Except for One Outlier

Fourteen property transfers were recorded in Sheffield between June 6 and July 5, but only five carried a sale price by the time records were checked. Prices ranged from $72,730 to $560,000, with a median of $85,000.

Email Text Facebook X

SHEFFIELD -- Fourteen property transfers were recorded at the Southern Berkshire Registry of Deeds for Sheffield between June 6 and July 5, but only five carried a sale price by the time records were reviewed. The month's priciest recorded transaction, a $560,000 sale on Valley View Road, stood well above the rest of the market.

MARKET OVERVIEW

Of the 14 deed entries recorded during the period, five included a sale price, ranging from $72,730 to $560,000, with a median of $85,000. One additional entry was a nominal-consideration transfer and is not counted toward the price range or median. The remaining eight entries have no price on file yet, which is typical for recently recorded deeds and does not indicate the parties withheld the amount. With only five of 14 entries showing a price, the recorded sales activity for the period cannot yet be fully assessed; the raw count of 14 transfers is notable, but most dollar figures remain pending.

TOP SALES

The five priced transactions, ranked highest to lowest

42 Valley View Road sold for $560,000 on June 12. Susan G. Segall was the seller; Greylock Federal Credit Union was the buyer.

216 South Street sold for $104,502 on June 18. Douglas J. and Elizabeth B. Pendergist were the sellers; the buyers were the Sheffield CDBG Housing Rehabilitation Program and the Town of Sheffield.

243 Hulett Hill Road sold for $85,000 on June 18. The sellers were Melissa A. Noe and James P. Noe Jr. No buyer was listed in the deed data.

392 Bears Den Road sold for $83,357 on June 18. Arthur Wright was the seller; the buyers were the Sheffield CDBG Housing Rehabilitation Program and the Town of Sheffield.

221 Polikoff Road sold for $72,730 on June 10. The sellers were Rehannah E. Weinstein and Renannah Weinstein; the buyers were Dart Collateral Manager LLC and COM LLC.

NEIGHBORHOOD BREAKDOWN

By price tier among the five priced sales: one transaction topped $500,000 (42 Valley View Road); one fell in the $100,000-to-$500,000 range (216 South Street); and three were under $100,000 (243 Hulett Hill Road, 392 Bears Den Road and 221 Polikoff Road). No street had more than one priced sale. Outside the priced group, 153 East Main Street appears twice in the dataset, recorded June 22 with two different sellers, Michael Farrell and Colin Whitaker, and no price or buyer listed for either entry.

MARKET NOTES

Two of the five priced sales, at 216 South Street and 392 Bears Den Road, involved the Sheffield CDBG Housing Rehabilitation Program and the Town of Sheffield as buyers. Several unpriced entries show patterns worth noting without speculation on motive: 374 East Road was transferred by Holly G. Coon, trustee, and Timothy A. Coon, trustee; 997 Foley Road was transferred by George A. Oleen and the estate of Marion E. Oleen; and 199 Canaan Road was transferred from Arnold C. Agar Jr. and Diana L. Agar to the same two names. One entry, with no street address given, was a nominal-consideration transfer under $10,000 from Priscilla J. Stevens to Cavalry SPV I LLC; it is not a market sale and is not included in any price figures. Two entries, 334 Clayton Road and 549 Sheffield Plain Road, list a bank or financial entity as seller or buyer (Wells Fargo Bank N.A./Freedom Mortgage Corp. and L Evans LLC/Pittsfield Cooperative Bank Inc., respectively), with no price yet recorded. Beds, baths and square footage were not available in the deed data for any property, so no property-type or price-per-square-foot comparisons can be made this period.


Recorded Deeds

Source: Registry of Deeds. Sale amounts shown as recorded; transfers without a disclosed consideration are noted as such.

Jun 8 - Jun 14
DateAddressGrantorGranteeSale Amount
Jun 8374 East RdCoon Holly G Tr.; Coon Timothy A Tr.Not yet available
Jun 8(no address)Stevens Priscilla JCavalry Spv I LLCNominal
Jun 9549 Sheffield Plain RdL Evans LLC; Pittsfield Cooperative Bank IncNot yet available
Jun 10221 Polikoff RdWeinstein Rehannah E; Weinstein RenannahDart Collateral Manager LLC; Com LLC$72,730
Jun 1242 Valley View RdSegall Susan GGreylock Federal Credit Union$560,000
Jun 12997 Foley RdOleen George A; Oleen Marion E EstNot yet available
Jun 12199 Canaan RdAgar Arnold C Jr.; Agar Diana LAgar Arnold C Jr.; Agar Diana LNot yet available
Jun 15 - Jun 21
DateAddressGrantorGranteeSale Amount
Jun 17334 Clayton RdWells Fargo Bank Na; Muir Karen AFreedom Mortgage CorpNot yet available
Jun 1730 Pine LnBartow Kenneth; Bartow DianeJordano ChristopherNot yet available
Jun 18216 South StPendergist Douglas J; Pendergist Elizabeth BSheffield Cdbg Housing Rehabilitation Program; Sheffield Town$104,502
Jun 18243 Hulett Hill RdNoe Melissa A; Noe James P Jr.$85,000
Jun 18392 Bears Den RdWright ArthurSheffield Cdbg Housing Rehabilitation Program; Sheffield Town$83,357
Jun 22 - Jun 28
DateAddressGrantorGranteeSale Amount
Jun 22153 E Main StFarrell MichaelNot yet available
Jun 22153 East Main StWhitaker ColinNot yet available

Compiled from official town feeds, community organizations, and local press. Outside reporting is attributed inline.

Share this story

Email Text Facebook X

Know someone in Sheffield who follows town government? Share Townbrief Sheffield: they can sign up free.

Share this story

Email Text Facebook X

Anyone can open a shared story. Members' stories show the free part and a sign-up line to people who are not members.